Homeowner content is free. We may earn a commission when you click links through our site. Advertiser Disclosure

If you were alive during the mid 90s, then you probably remember Beanie Babies were one of the most popular collectible toys around. In fact, Beanie Babies were so popular that there were 822 different variations of animals created over the past few decades.

Hold On!

Before you part with your collectibles, uncover these 8 Genius Money Moves to Score $500+ in Free Cash This Week! Why sell when you can earn more effortlessly?

These plush toys have also found their way back onto the market thanks to collectors. So, you might be able to turn that old collection in your basement or attic into some extra cash.

That’s why this guide is covering where to sell Beanie Babies, how to value your collection, and tips for making the process much easier.

Want even more fast ideas to earn besides selling? Checkout:

Where to Sell Beanie Babies

If you’re looking for a quick way to sell your Beanie Babies for money, you have quite a few options. And this includes online and local selling options, so there’s something for everyone!

1. eBay

eBay, one of the most popular online marketplaces in the world, is an excellent choice for selling Beanie Babies.

This isn’t too surprising when you consider eBay is one of the best ways to flip stuff for profit, including collectibles like Beanie Babies and even random things like old Disney VHS tapes or other rare items.

eBay-sell-Beanie-Baby

eBay already has a designated section specifically for Beanie Babies. This makes it easier to value your Beanie Baby collection and gives you examples of what sells well.

The main downside of eBay is for selling extremely valuable beanie babies. If you have something worth any more than $150, you’re probably better off with a different option below.

2. Facebook Marketplace

The Facebook Marketplace has grown into one of the largest local marketplaces for people to buy and sell their belongings.

And, if you live in a decently-sized city, there’s a decent chance someone in your area is looking to expand their Beanie Baby collection.

Facebook-Marketplace-sell-Beanie-Babies

So, if you want to sell your Beanie Babies for cash, take some photos of your collection and list them on Facebook.

From there, buyers can contact you to ask questions about your Beanie Babies. A lot of buyers also message to negotiate, so prepare for this possibility and know your absolute bottom-dollar price.

Facebook lets you ship products you sell on the marketplace, but this platform is really best for in-person cash sales.

The locality of deals makes it hard to get the most eyes possible on your listings, but that’s the trade off for a higher valuation and selling your Beanie Babies for cash.

3. PlushCollector

As the name implies, PlushCollector is a very unique marketplace for selling Beanie Babies and other collectibles like Funko Pop figures and Star Wars toys.

But, PlushCollector is one of the best places to sell Beanie Babies for cash because it specializes in plush collectibles.

PlushCollector-Beanie-Babies

And, if you can find your Beanie Baby model on its website, PlushCollector buys it directly from you for the price that it’s listed at. Overall, PlushCollector is a safe and secure way for you to get rid of your plush toys at a pretty fair price.

You might get a lower price than if you sold your Beanie Babies on an independent marketplace to a collector, but PlushCollector is one of the simplest options for sellers. PlushCollector also accepts collections and offers free shipping labels on selling orders of $25 or more. 

If you don’t want to deal with all the hassle of listing all your items and waiting for them to sell without guarantee, definitely consider selling Beanie Babies on PlushCollector.

👉 Homeowner Tip: The next time you shop online, download the free Capital One Shopping extension first. It automatically applies available coupon codes at 30,000+ stores to help you save on autopilot. And it can also help you save on Amazon too!

Capital One Shopping compensates us when you sign up with our partner link.

4. Etsy

Believe it or not, the antiques and handmade items marketplace is one of the better places to sell these plush animals.

Many of the Beanie Babies that actually sell on Etsy have a value between $50-$100. This price tag can also include collections of lesser value babies.

Etsy-Beanie-Babies

However, some sellers list rare Beanie Babies on Etsy, so you can still find a range of prices. Before you sell, quickly search on Etsy for the specific Beanie Babies you have and see what they sell for.

You’ll need to create an Etsy seller account and list each item with as much detail as possible, even if it’s a collection. Keep in mind that there is a listing fee of $0.20 per item and a seller fee of up to 5% when the transaction is made.

The listing fee isn’t too bad, but the transaction fee is higher than selling on marketplaces like eBay or Mercari, so keep this in mind!

5. Sell2BBNovelties

Another way to sell your Beanie Babies is to sell directly to Sell2BBNovelties. Like PlushCollector, there’s a specific section of the site that’s meant for selling Beanie Babies.

Sell2BBNovelties

This novelties website buys  a variety of collectibles from people, including:

  • Beanie Babies
  • Funko POP figurines
  • Yugioh and Pokemon cards
  • LEGO
  • Action figures

All you have to do is look up the model of Beanie Baby you’re selling, get a quote, and then ship it off to Sell2BBNovelties. From there, the company inspects your Beanie Babies. If it approves your shipment, you get paid and it’s that simple.

There is one downside to Sell2BBNovelties; it only buys new or mint condition Beanie Babies. So, if your collection is a bit worn down, you might be better off with a different website.

However, sellers get free shipping if the item you’re selling is worth $30 or more. Overall, Sell2BBNovelties is one of the best places to sell Beanie Babies for cash, provided your collection is in mind condition.

6. Sell4Value

Sell4Value is ideal for selling Beanie Baby collections, especially if you want to make money fast and don’t care for nickel and dimming your way into the best deal possible.

Sell4Value buys thousands of plush toys every month. The company only buys new or mint plush toys including Disney, Warner Bros, and Coca-Cola toys (if you have any lying around).

Sell4Value

Sell4Value also buys most common Beanie Babies for $0.40 – $0.50 per toy, depending on how big your collection is.

If you’re in a position where you have 1 or 2 high value beanie babies and over 100 common ones, sell the common ones here and post the other 2 on other sites you can sell Beanie Babies on to get the most money possible.

7. Mercari

Mercari is a popular selling app that lets you quickly sell goods like apparel, electronics, toys, and video games.

However, Mercari is also one of the best ways to sell Beanie Babies online due to the marketplace size and ease of use.

Mercari-Beanie-Babies-for-sale

To start selling on Mercari, all you have to do is download the app, create an account, and list the Beanie Babies you’re selling. It’s completely free to make a listing, and but Mercari fees charge 10% of the final sale price.

This is a hefty fee compared to selling to some Mercari alternatives, but Mercari is speedy and keeps things simple. Plus, buyers normally pay for shipping, and Mercari is free, so you can always create a listing while you try out some other online marketplaces as well.

Just be sure to follow some Mercari selling tricks like adding multiple high quality photos, listing the condition of your Beanie Babies, and being prompt with responding to potential buyers.

Extra Reading – The 10 Best Things To Sell On Mercari.

8. Craigslist

Like Facebook Marketplace, Craigslist is a popular marketplace people use to sell all sorts of things for cash to people in their area.

And, depending on where you live, the market for Beanie Babies in your area could be extremely valuable on Craigslist. However, not every place is like this. For example, my area currently has Beanie Baby collections that are selling for no more than $1 per toy.

Craigslist-sell-Beanie-Baby

If you’re trying to get rid of a massive collection of beanie babies for cash, Craigslist is likely an excellent option for you. But, if you have rare Beanie Babies or want to get the most value possible, various online marketplaces are probably a better choice.

9. Flea Markets

If you’re selling high value Beanie Babies along with a few other valuable antiques that need to go, selling at a flea market could be a lucrative option worth trying.

You have to rent out a selling space at flea markets, which is an upfront cost. However, if you’re selling Beanie Babies and other collectibles or stuff you want to get rid of, you can normally cover the rental expense with a few sales.

Additionally, some of the people that come to flea markets are specifically looking for items that you’re selling. Many people are familiar with Beanie Babies too, which makes them a recognizable purchase for anyone who wanders around the market.

Extra Reading – 10+ Ways To Make Money From Home.

10. Ruby Lane

Ruby Lane is another way to sell Beanie Babies online, and it’s a particularly good option if you have some vintage Beanie Babies.

This marketplace specializes in antiques and collectibles. And when I searched the site, people were selling Beanie Babies for $25 to $250 or more depending on the model.

ruby lane sell Beanie Babies

Listing is free, but you pay a $25 monthly fee to host your shop. However, Ruby Lane waives this fee if you add at least 15 items per month, so this is a decent option if you’re starting a resale side hustle.

You also pay a 9.9% service fee on sales, so factor this into your listing price!

11. Pawn Shops

If you need money by tomorrow, you can always take a visit to your local pawn shop.

There are plenty of things you can pawn, including collectibles like Beanie Babies, comic books, antiques, watches, and other collectibles. And the bonus of pawn shops is that you can get same-day cash.

However, you need some vintage, valuable Beanie Babies if a pawn shop is going to make an offer. Also note that pawn shops don’t offer full price since they need to resell your merchandise for a profit. For this reason, I only suggest pawning things if you need quick cash.

12. OfferUp

One final idea for where to sell Beanie Babies is to sell locally through OfferUp.

OfferUp is similar to the Facebook Marketplace and lets you create listings for free. Local buyers then message you to negotiate and arrange a meet-up for the sale.

OfferUp Sell Beanie Babies

Popular things to sell on OfferUp include apparel, electronics, shoes, and toys. However, you can find people selling collectibles like Beanie Babies and sports cards.

You can also sell online with OfferUp, but it charges around 13% in fees for online sales, so in-person is your best bet. And with some OfferUp seller tips like writing posts that rank and posting listings at the right time, you might find local buyers pretty quickly!

Who Buys Beanie Babies Near Me?

The best place to sell Beanie Babies locally is likely to private buyers. You can find them on Facebook Marketplace, Craigslist, and other classified websites. You can also try selling at pawn shops or comic stores.

If you have a rare collection, selling online is likely the better choice since you can host an auction.

What Influences Beanie Baby Prices?

It doesn’t matter if you want to sell Beanie Babies or other rare collectibles like Pokemon cards or Yugioh cards; you need to know how to value your rare assets.

There are several other factors that influence the value of your Beanie Baby collection:

  1. Generation
  2. Rarity
  3. Condition
  4. Certificate of Authenticity
  5. Hang Tags
  6. Tush Tags
  7. It’s history

Older generations are usually more valuable than newer ones. Some Beanie Babies are considered unique or rare while others are just common. Additionally, the better condition the baby has been kept in, the more it’s worth. If it still has a certificate of authenticity, you could have an extremely valuable item on your hands.

If the hang tag and tush tag match, that increases the value. If not, the tags at least tell you more information about the Beanie Baby so you can get a proper valuation.

How Does Beanie Baby Appraisal Work?

The best way to check the value of your Beanie Baby is to look up the model and price on websites like PlushCollector, eBay, and Sell2BBNovelties. These websites let you check what your Beanie Baby has sold for in the past or is currently being sold for, so it’s a fast way to get a rough valuation.

What Are The Most Valuable Beanie Babies?

According to 90s Toys, a website that specializes in rare toys and collectibles, some of the most valuable Beanie Babies to sell include:

  • Spot The Dog
  • Squealer The Pig
  • Patti The Platypus
  • Cabbie The Bear
  • Chocolate The Moose
  • Pinchers The Lobster
  • Splash The Whale
  • Legs The Frog
  • Splash The Dolphin

In some cases, the original nine Beanie Babies have sold for $5,000 to $10,000 on marketplaces like eBay. And many other rare Beanie Babies can sell for a few hundred dollars to the right collector.

How To Sell Beanie Babies – Tips For Starting

If you’re a beginner when it comes to selling plush toys, there are a good few ideas you can implement into your selling strategy.

Take a look at these tips for selling:

  • Do Your Research: Doing your homework ahead of time ensures you value your Beanie Babies properly.
  • Try Several Markets: List your Beanie Babies on multiple marketplaces to maximize exposure.
  • Learn The Terminology: Familiarize yourself with what influences Beanie Baby prices and all of the terminology in the space.
  • Seek Appraisals: If you have rare Beanie Babies that are potentially worth thousands of dollars, it’s a good idea to get them appraised.
  • Condition Is Key: The look and even the smell of your Beanie Babies play a massive role in value, so keeping your collection in mint condition is vital.
  • Look For The Original 9: The original 9 Beanie Babies are incredibly valuable, so check your collection to see if you’re sitting on a hidden gem.
rare-Beanie-baby
A rare Beanie Baby that’s in mint condition.

The real key in selling Beanie Babies for money is to do as much research as you possibly can so that you go into a sale knowing more than you need to.

Extra Reading – The Best Ways To Earn Money With Your Home.

Final Thoughts

At the end of the day, you have plenty of options to sell your Beanie Babies for money. Online marketplaces get you the most visibility, and you can sell to collectible websites like Sell2BBNovelties or PlushCollector if you want to make money as fast as possible.

In contrast, local marketplaces and marketplaces like eBay let you haggle a bit more and get the most value.

Ultimately, listing your beanie babies on multiple marketplaces can give you the advantage to maximize your earning potential.

If someone on eBay offers you $200 for your collection and someone on Facebook Marketplace offers you $300, then you can safely make a decision.