If you’re anything like me, you spent a lot of time growing up playing Magic The Gathering.
Magic The Gathering, or MTG, was a large part of my childhood. I remember playing against kids on the school bus every day, and at recess, and then on weekends if I saw my cousin.
But people stop playing at some point in time. Or maybe you need some quick money and want to sell those Magic The Gathering cards that are collecting dust in your basement right now.
That’s why this post is covering where to sell Magic cards, as well as tips for selling and how to value your collection.
Looking for more quick money ideas? Checkout:
- Branded Surveys: Share your opinion to earn free gift cards and PayPal cash!
- Arrived (U.S.): Start investing in income-generating rental properties with just $100!
Where To Sell Magic Cards
If you want to earn money online by selling Magic cards, you have plenty of options. After all, there are so many online games shops and stores that buy MTG cards all the time.
Plus, you can also consider selling Magic The Gathering cards to local collectors and enthusiasts if you prefer quick cash sales.
1. TCGplayer
TCGplayer is one of the most popular ways to sell Magic cards online, as well as other popular games like Pokemon and Yugioh.
The easiest way to start selling is to list your cards on the TCGplayer marketplace.
This lets you sell cards directly to an active community, and you can create listings for free. One perk is that you also get live pricing data so you can price your MTG cards competitively.
Marketplace fees depend on your selling level, and new sellers pay a 10.25% commission fee plus PayPal fees if you choose PayPal cash for payment.
However, you can also become a direct seller and ship your inventory to TCGplayer before you sell. When you make a sale, TCGplayer is the one that packs and ships the order.
This is similar to Amazon FBA, and it lets you focus on selling instead of order fulfillment.
Overall, direct selling is best for more serious MTG card flippers. But the main marketplace is a great way to offload your valuable Magic cards if you need a fast sale.
2. eBay
Unsurprisingly, another one of the best places to sell Magic cards is to list them on eBay.
People sell all kinds of collectibles on eBay, ranging from sports cards to MTG cards.
You can list for free unless you’re listing over 250 cards per month. eBay supports action selling, but for cards, it could be best to set fixed prices unless you’re selling very rare cards.
Some sellers offer free shipping, while others cover the cost, so research what MTG sellers are doing when you create your listings.
The advantage of selling Magic cards on eBay is that you get access to a massive marketplace of active buyers.
However, eBay charges 5% for sellers of collectible card games, so factor this price into your bottom line.
And to stay under the 250 free monthly listing requirement, consider selling your MTG cards in sets or boxes.
3. Card Kingdom
Card Kingdom is another reliable way to sell Magic The Gathering cards that’s similar to TCGplayer.
The site has been buying MTG cards and other collectibles since 1999, so it has a long history in the space.
You can also sell cards individually or in bulk, so it’s a great option for selling rare MTG cards and then basic cards like lands.
Bulk selling is very simple, and you basically enter the number and types of cards you’re selling, pack a giant box, and ship it to Card Kingdom.
Single sales, which are for more expensive cards, go through a grading process and have to be packed differently.
In either case, Card Kingdom pays you with PayPal money or store credit once it grades all your cards.
As for how much you get per card, it all depends on that card’s buy price and condition.
As you can see from the table, Card Kingdom pays anywhere from 30% to 90% of a card’s buy-price depending on the type of card and condition.
This is honestly a very fair and transparent system. And if you have cards in pristine condition, Card Kingdom is one of the best places to sell Magic cards.
4. Channel Fireball
Channel Fireball is an incredibly popular site in the MTG world. The site began in 2009 but actually has its roots set back in 1993 when it used to be called Superstars of Sports.
You have to be a business to sell on Channel Fireball’s marketplace, so this is only a useful website for serious sellers.
But if you run a hobby and games store or card game store, you can register as a professional seller and start listing your Magic cards on the marketplace.
5. Star City Games
If you want a variety of selling options, Star City Games is one of the best places to sell MTG cards out there.
This hobby and card games retailer offers four options for sellers:
- Buylist: Star City Games maintains an active buylist with current prices and pays you for your individual cards with PayPal. You can also get a 30% store credit bonus with this method.
- Ship + Sell: This is the best option for selling Magic cards in bulk, and you get an offer from Star City Games after sending in your collection.
- Visit The Store: To sell Magic cards in person, you can visit the Star City Games center in Roanoke, Virginia.
- They Come To You: If you’re selling a massive collection, Star City Games can send a representative to you in several different states.
Star City Games has been in business a long time, and the variety of selling options is a massive perk.
If anything, check its buylist and see how much you can get for your rare MTG cards and then send the rest with the bulk shipping option.
6. Mercari
Mercari is a popular selling app where you can sell anything from cars to collectible card games like Magic The Gathering.
Listing on Mercari is completely fee, and you create all your listings through its easy-to-use mobile app.
Popular things to sell on Mercari include toys, electronics, and clothing. However, plenty of people are selling Magic cards on the marketplace.
There’s a 10% Mercari Seller fee, so keep this fee in mind when making your listings!
Buyers normally pay for shipping, which is a plus, although a popular Mercari trick is to offer free shipping and cover the cost to entice more buyers.
7. Dave & Adam’s
One final way to sell Magic cards online is to sell to Dave and Adam’s.
This cards and collectibles website buys everything from basketball cards to vintage Magic cards, and the selling process is simple.
Like other retailers, Dave and Adam’s has an active buylist where you can see the Magic singles the site is interested in buying.
You get paid in 48 hours after the company receives your cards, and payment options include PayPal cash or store credit.
Again, having a buylist is nice because you know exactly how much you’re getting for different Magic cards depending on their rarity and condition.
Like the other sites on this list, check out Dave and Adam’s buylist and compare it to the other retailers to see where you can get the best prices.
8. CardShark
If you’re still wondering where to sell Magic cards, you can always consider a peer-to-peer marketplace like CardShark.
This MTG reseller has been in business for almost 20 years. And as a seller, it helps you find other MTG fans you can sell your individual or bulk cards to.
All you have to do is submit the cards you want to sell with CardShark by using its buylist. From there, CardShark lists the cards on its website until they sell.
You don’t pay any listing fees, and CardShark simply takes a 15% fee for each sale.
The downside of selling Magic cards with CardShark is that you have to worry about shipping cards to buyers. And you only have three days to confirm orders.
But the site pays out sellers monthly, and it’s one of the best places to sell bulk Magic cards since you can find a steady stream of buyers for your collection.
9. Local Games Stores
My local comic book and games store was where I bought my first MTG booster pack and, later on, full set.
This is how many players discover the beauty of MTG. But if you want to sell your Magic cards, you can always go back to your local games stores to see if they’ll make an offer.
Many stores are only interested in buying more valuable cards, and you might not get the highest offer.
But you never know: your store might still be interested in bulk sales or buying larger collections, not just foils and rares.
10. Facebook Marketplace
Another way to sell Magic cards is to list them for sale on the Facebook Marketplace.
Collectibles are a popular thing to sell on Facebook alongside categories like electronics, clothing, shoes, tools, and toys.
A quick search in my area shows plenty of people selling MTG cards, and if you live in a major city, you can probably find some buyers.
You can list and sell for free, and all you need is a Facebook account. And Facebook Marketplace is one of the most popular local selling sites out there.
The downside of Facebook selling is that you might get some lowball offers and you have to negotiate with buyers.
But sales are in cash, so you can keep all the money. Just meet in a public, safe area when making the sale!
11. Card Game Conventions
Magic The Gathering is one of the most popular card games on earth. And Wizards of The Coast and other companies do an excellent job at running conventions and events.
A quick Google search for “MTG conventions” should yield plenty of events coming up in major cities near you.
So, don’t be afraid to attend this event, meet fellow MTG fans, and see if you can find retail or hobby buyers to sell your collection to.
12. OfferUp
OfferUp is another popular marketplace that’s great for selling sports equipment, collectibles, home goods, clothing, and many other categories.
People also sell Magic cards on OfferUp, and the listing process is basically the same as Facebook Marketplace.
The main difference is that OfferUp also lets you sell online if you don’t mind shipping your goods to the buyer.
Buyers usually pay for shipping, but OfferUp charges a 12.9% fee for selling online, which is higher than most retailers and even eBay and Mercari.
I suggest selling your Magic cards in person if you use OfferUp to avoid fees. Just be prepared for some negotiating with potential buyers.
13. MTG Tournaments
One final place to sell MTG cards is to sell cards to other players at tournaments.
Like finding conventions, you can view a list of upcoming MTG Premier Tournaments or smaller local tournaments online.
Just be careful with being too salesy at these tournaments, and read the rules to see if this sort of thing is even allowed.
If anything, you can always talk with close friends and sell or swap cards with them if they’re open to the idea.
What Influences Magic The Gathering Card Prices?
Now that you know some of the best places for selling magic cards, it’s important to cover some of the factors that influence the prices of your cards.
Some MTG cards, like Black Lotus, are worth anywhere from $100,000 to $250,000 depending on condition, despite the fact that the card is banned in almost every edition of the game.
Here are some factors that contribute to how expensive your Magic The Gathering cards are:
- Rarity: Wizards of the Coast, the company behind MTG, decides how many cards to print. Therefore, rarity for cards depends on how many cards are in circulation, with rare cards often having higher price-tags.
- Supply vs Demand: The secondary resale marketplace for Magic cards largely depends on supply and demand. If a card is currently popular in the meta, more players probably want it for their decks, increasing card value.
- Card Condition: Cards in pristine condition are worth more. This is the case for selling Magic cards, Pokemon cards, Yugioh cards, and other collectibles.
- Age: Since MTG is such an old game, there are numerous game formats people play with. Some of the older formats, like Vintage, allow very old cards. Cards from the early days of Magic The Gathering can fetch high prices because they’re rare and old, especially if you sell to Vintage players.
- Tournament Usage: Just like supply and demand, if cards are being heavily used in MTG tournaments because they’re in the meta, this can increase card prices.
For a helping hand in finding card prices, you can consult MTG Price. It has prices for cards in all sets, so it’s useful for getting a rough idea of how much your cards are worth.
Tips For Selling Your Magic The Gathering Collection
Now that you know the best ways to sell Magic cards, it’s time to cover a few tips you should keep in mind to make the selling process much easier:
- Do Your Research: When selling Magic cards, research is everything. There are thousands upon thousands of cards out there, each with their own price and demand. This is a daunting task to sift through, but there are plenty of buy lists and pricing databases you can use to start valuing your collection.
- Organization Is Key: It’s important to organize your MTG cards to make the selling process easier. Some sellers organize by set, rarity, but also factor in things like card condition so they have different categories of cards to sell.
- Know Your Bottom Price: Once you have a rough idea of how much your collection is worth and how much your rarest cards are worth, start figuring out your bottom-price. People will haggle with you, so you need to know what numbers work for you and when to walk away.
- Value Your Time: Selling MTG cards in bulk is the fastest way to get cash for your cards. However, selling cards individually can get a better price. Decide how much you value your time and find a solution that works. You can always sell your rarest cards individually and then sell the rest in bulk.
This video from YouTuber Tolarian Community College provides a great guide on how to sell Magic The Gathering cards by using the TCGplayer buylist:
This guide covers how a MTG buylist works, what the listing process is like, and the pros and cons of selling through a buylist at lower-than-market-prices.
Methodology
To find where to sell MTG cards, I researched over two dozen online and in-person options. The main factors I considered when making this list include:
- Ease of selling
- Types of cards you can sell
- Any potential selling fees or shipping fees
I also wanted to include a combination of online and in-person cash options for selling your MTG cards. And as a former MTG player myself, I wanted to make sure other players have easy, low-fee options for selling their collections.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Selling Magic Cards Worth It?
Selling MTG cards is worth it if you’re done playing the game and have a decent number of cards for sale. This is especially true if you have old cards or rare cards that can fetch a high price.
If you only have a small collection and no rare cards, you probably can’t get too much for your collection. But you can always list them online or sell them at your local games store so you at least get something.
How Much Can I Sell MTG Cards For?
Common MTG cards generally sell for pennies, so this is why people often sell basic cards in bulk to make it worth their time. Uncommon and rare cards can sell for $10 to $20 or more. And foil or ultra rare cards can sell for hundreds or even thousands of dollars depending on card condition and the demand.
Final Thoughts
I hope our guide on where to sell Magic cards helps you turn your MTG collection into cash.
Between online marketplaces, buylists, and local games stores, there are so many options out there.
Just make sure to do your research! This is the most important step in selling, and it’s how you ensure you’re getting a fair price for your cards.
Looking for even more ways to make extra money? Checkout:
